Current Avatar:
No Avatar image uploaded
No Avatar image uploaded
NHL Trade Rumors Member Posts
BonesJackson33's Profile
BonesJackson33's Posts and Other Poster's Replies To BonesJackson33's Posts
To BonesJackson33's last 5 rumours posts
To BonesJackson33's last 5 rumour replies
BonesJackson33's rumours posts with other poster's replies to BonesJackson33's rumours posts
17 Jun 2016 15:38:25
Hey guys what do you think of an oilers flyer's trade? They seem very talked about.
Edmonton
4th overall
Griffin Reinhart
Nail Yakupov
Philadelphia
Ivan Provorov
I was thinking giving Reinhart so Edmonton does not completely overkill left handed shots
And Yakupov may turn around with new teammates
Then Philadelphia takes Tkatchuk
Just an idea :)
1.) 17 Jun 2016 16:29:37
Nah pretty sure provorov is going to be a stud, and the backbone of the Flyers defence for years to come.
2.) 17 Jun 2016 16:40:18
Provorov is going to be great, but that's way too much to give up for a dman that hasn't played a single NHL game. If we are trading the pick, there needs to be somewhat of an established dman coming back. And yes, a RH shot would be nice.
3.) 17 Jun 2016 17:28:18
You traded a LHD but got one back. Also the 4th overall would probably be close to his value. Just not a good fit IMO.
4.) 17 Jun 2016 17:32:53
The fourth overall is too much. Take that out and add either Davidson or Osterlie plus a later pick and I like it.
Ivan is a left shot keep in mind.
22 Mar 2016 04:16:28
Thanks for the responses so far! And totally I know some will never happen it is just fun doing value trades as close as I can :)
So this time I will try a more realistic one
(well as realistic as I can see it haha)
New York Islanders
Ryan Strome
Minnesota Wild
Jonas Brodin
Then trade
Travis Hamonic to Minnesota
For Erik Haula and 2nd round pick
Seems like alright ideas.
To be honest if anything send me good conversation about potential replacements in the trades I post. I love the funny comments but am genuinely curious what people think of what to replace with what. It's a blast :)
Thanks guys!
1.) 22 Mar 2016 14:30:38
I think the Jonas Brodin trade for Ryan Strome trade is pretty close but Minnesota does think highly of Brodin even with a surplus of young D. Strome so far has numbers in the Ryan Spooner ball park and still has great potential but has been really inconsistent with the Islanders and has played the least amount of games of all the top 10 picks from that 2011 draft. The Hamonic trade is very one sided in Minnesota's favor. Travis Hamonic is a valuable player and is worth more than a second round and a 3rd liner who's riding a hot streak.
2.) 22 Mar 2016 18:49:06
Awesome thanks for the feedback
To be honest I just tried to see what Brodin value would be in a trade, since I saw him mentioned and Eve offered for Johansen. Totally not comparing Strome to Johansen. Then figured it would be fun to. see what they could get for Hamonic to round it all back
Kind of lose a defensman but replace him?
Good point on Haula and thanks again!
21 Mar 2016 06:33:12
Another one I was thinking of since Drouin wanted out and the Flyer's where mentioned why not trade
Tampa Bay
Drouin
Philadelphia
Provorov
I figure value for value. I see so many trades here that are straight crazy or just trying to justify an amazing player for straight garbage or spare players hahah it's always a good laugh.
But I figure value for value. Not like Philadelphia hurts for defensively prospects. They could use a good forward prospect.
And Yzerman gets his young dman who will come up and both will be integral parts hopefully in new situations
Again these are just some fun ideas to me :)
1.) 21 Mar 2016 07:11:35
NO CHANCE.
Provorov is an absolute gem, philly wouldn't even consider giving him up for Drouin.
2.) 21 Mar 2016 09:28:19
Hmmmm. Sanheim and a second?
I dig it though. And I guess Provorov does not have the Drouin issues haha.
3.) 21 Mar 2016 10:47:51
Philly hangs up as soon as they hear Provorov. Maybe a package around Sanheim?
4.) 21 Mar 2016 11:56:59
Elite F prospect for elite D prospect. Don't think it's as far off as you guys make it seem especially with Philly being stacked with D prospects and light at F but I do agree tampa would have to add another quality piece at leaSt.
5.) 21 Mar 2016 15:07:02
Jb I agree, but they aren't trading Provorov kids going to be great for them.
6.) 21 Mar 2016 19:29:22
Bud sorry didn't mean to say it's likely or doable. Just going from a value standpoint. I don't see Provorov going anywhere either. I still feel Drouin will he the best player in a Drouin trade and either get someone more established or multiple pieces.
21 Mar 2016 06:29:25
New to this site, always read but looks super fun
Anyhow my idea for a trade would be
Edmonton Oilers
Leon Draisaitl
Toronto Maple Leafs
Morgan Reilly
Helps the leafs rebuild, especially if they did win the draft and get Austin Mathews for 1-2 down the middle and Edmonton gets their top pairing D man. I know this leaves the leafs down a really good defensman so maybe Yandle can be signed in free agency?
Anyhow just new and looked fun hope to hear thoughts :)
1.) 21 Mar 2016 07:11:57
Edm blocks your number.
2.) 21 Mar 2016 11:37:35
@Chirp why? Draisaitl has 48 points in 65 games now (very impressive) but has slowed down considerably since that torrid start of his (as you guys often like to mention with Parayko) and it definitely doesn't hurt when you get to play with a top 10 winger in the NHL either. Yes Rielly only has 31 in 71 but when you that he only started to get PP time after the Phaneuf trade and the highest point scorer on the team only has 37 points I would say that's very impressive. Not to mention that he is playing 25 minutes a night against the other teams best players and has done a pretty good job of it despite playing with the turnover machine in Marincin.
3.) 21 Mar 2016 11:38:24
Both teams respectively decline IMO.
4.) 21 Mar 2016 15:14:58
Not a Chance from Toronto Rielly is about to establish into a # 1 Defencemen he is playing unbelievable lately getting 28 min a night. Toronto has Marner, Nylander, Kadri who can play Center not to mention the 20 percent chance at Matthews. And ill throw in the Stamkos sega because you all love it. We have absolutely no top D prospects which needs to be fixed can't win with just forwards. *cough* Oilers *cough*.
5.) 21 Mar 2016 17:07:57
Morgan Reily is not a number one dman. He is just slotted in the top pairing.
6.) 21 Mar 2016 17:07:57
Morgan Reily is not a number one dman. He is just slotted in the top pairing.
7.) 21 Mar 2016 17:26:31
"about to" - Tank read it twice next time.
8.) 21 Mar 2016 17:51:43
Interesting trade actually probably would benefit both players. When I watch Draisaitl play I see some similarities to Kopitar and anyteam would want that. If I were a GM I'd lean towards Reilly and probably would take him if he were RHD. Tough call, as others have said above both teams decline, would be an interesting proposal though.
9.) 21 Mar 2016 18:16:03
The last thing Toronto needs to do is trade away Defensemen, especially when Mo is our only legit cornerstone on D. No disrespect to Oilers, Drais is a great young player but it doesn't really make sense to Toronto given they are likely to win Matthews and potentially land Stamkos. Draisaitl would be slotted as 3C which is an insult to a player of his calibre.
TL;DR
Both teams say no.
10.) 21 Mar 2016 19:04:50
Hey guys thanks a tonne for reading so far! It's a blast reading comments.
And you know what I will admit I completely forgot about Nylander and manner so you are right. But just for the sake of argument, could you not have Marner on the RW like he has played before and roll 3 strong centres?
Otherwise yeah besides Gardiner I can't really picture a reason to get rid of Reilly.
Thanks again guys :)
11.) 22 Mar 2016 00:32:12
I would rather keep Rielly.
BonesJackson33 has no Banter Posts
BonesJackson33's rumour replies
24 Jun 2016 17:28:37
Kind of how stupid you are with blues trades.
If it's not parayko for mcdavid nothing is good enough.
I truly think you just come on here to pass people off.
But hey man your always a blast to read because people hate you and your an idiot with trades haha.
22 Mar 2016 18:49:06
Awesome thanks for the feedback
To be honest I just tried to see what Brodin value would be in a trade, since I saw him mentioned and Eve offered for Johansen. Totally not comparing Strome to Johansen. Then figured it would be fun to. see what they could get for Hamonic to round it all back
Kind of lose a defensman but replace him?
Good point on Haula and thanks again!
21 Mar 2016 19:04:50
Hey guys thanks a tonne for reading so far! It's a blast reading comments.
And you know what I will admit I completely forgot about Nylander and manner so you are right. But just for the sake of argument, could you not have Marner on the RW like he has played before and roll 3 strong centres?
Otherwise yeah besides Gardiner I can't really picture a reason to get rid of Reilly.
Thanks again guys :)
21 Mar 2016 09:28:19
Hmmmm. Sanheim and a second?
I dig it though. And I guess Provorov does not have the Drouin issues haha.
BonesJackson33 has no Banter Replies