NHL Trade Rumors Member Posts


LMac0420's Profile

Current Avatar:
No Avatar image uploaded

LMac0420's Posts and Other Poster's Replies To LMac0420's Posts



To LMac0420's last 5 rumours posts


To LMac0420's last 5 banter posts


To LMac0420's last 5 rumour replies


LMac0420's rumours posts with other poster's replies to LMac0420's rumours posts


20 Jun 2024 19:47:21
Wild: Robertson, Toronto 4th round pick 2024

Leafs: Gustavsson

Change of scenery could benefit both players.
Robertson would be a good cheap top 9 scoring option for the Wild.
Gustavsson would be a decent tandem partner for Woll.

Also gives the Wild some cap relief.


1.) 20 Jun 2024 22:26:45
Tough to gauge what his value is. Maybe only a 3rd Rd pick would land Gustavsson. Me personally the Leafs need to big game hunt. Not a tandem to figure out what will is.

The Atlantic has proven time and time again (6 years straight I. The finals) that elite goaltending makes a big difference.

2.) 21 Jun 2024 19:43:48
Fair enough.
I’d like to see the leafs get an elite goaltender, I just don’t see them having the assets to be able to get one.
The only really elite goalie available is Saros, and unless Marner waives his NMC or they decide to move Cowan in a package, I think they’ll have to settle for a tandem.



13 Jun 2024 21:45:31
Toronto: Rasmus Anderson
Calgary: 1st Round Pick 2024, 5th Round Pick 2024, Fraser Minten, Timothey Liljegren




12 Jun 2024 19:43:55
Ducks: 1st Round Pick 2024 Leafs
1st Round Pick 2024 Islanders (Chicago)
4th Round Pick 2025 Rangers (Chicago)
Nick Robertson (Chicago)
(Retain 50% of John Gibson)

Blackhawks: Trevor Zegras
(Retain 50% of John Gibson)

Maple Leafs: John Gibson

I haven't watched the Ducks in a couple years and I know Zegras had a down year so I'm not 100% on his value. Also read that Chicago has interest in him.
Is this fair? If not who adds or subtracts?




11 Jun 2024 20:50:36
OTT: Ehlers
WPG: Chychrun


1.) 11 Jun 2024 21:09:59
Winnipeg has zero need for LHD, so the Jets should say no.

An Ehlers trade needs to fill a need for the Jets, like a top 4 RHD or 2C with term or team control.

2.) 13 Jun 2024 03:28:36
Memarcus, connor Murphy, a 3rd for Ehlers.



11 Jun 2024 20:32:36
LA: Rights to Laurent Brossoit
WPG: Rights to Matt Roy

LA: Rights to Ilya Samsonov, Rights to Timothey Liljegren
TML: Rights to Matt Roy, 6th Round Pick 2024

LA: Rights to Anthony Stolarz
FLA: 6th Round Pick 2025

LA Goalie tandem: Stolarz + Brossoit
Or Stolarz + Samsonov





LMac0420's banter posts with other poster's replies to LMac0420's banter posts


25 Jul 2021 15:09:54
Unknown Matthews Marner
Unknown Tavares Nylander
Robertson Kerfoot Mikheyev
Engvall Spezza Simmonds
Anderson Brooks

Reilly Brodie
Muzzin Holl


I Would like to see Hamonic or Hakanpaa rotating in and out of the bottom pair.

I Would like to see the resigning of Galchenyuk for a prove yourself year. He and Robertson can go back and forth on the 2nd and 3rd line.

I Would like to see Andersen back as well if possible on a 1 year deal to give him a better shot at more money somewhere else next off season. If not maybe a trade with Vancouver for Holtby half salary retained?

As a depth guy pick up Khaira to rotate in and out of the 4th line.

When it comes to the top line left wing i'm at a loss. Maybe someone who will come in on a 1 year team friendly deal? Anyone have an idea who to put there?


1.) 26 Jul 2021 16:59:36
Getting creative here. The leafs have 9 million in space and Brooks definitely makes the leafs roster he is a lock. He proved he’s NHL ready.

Saad 4 mil x 7
Sandin for a 2022 1st and b prospect
Galchenyuk 1.2 mil x 1 year
Bernier 2mil x 3
Gives the leafs about 2 mil extra in space






26 Jul 2016 14:24:53
I've been trying to work on my values a little more so hopefully I'm getting closer with this.

Toronto Trades: JVR, Gardiner and Sens 2nd 2017
Winnipeg Trade: Trouba, Comrie and 4th or 5th 2017

Is it fair value? If not, who adds?
Yes JVR may walk after his final 2 years, if that be the case I'm sure the Jets management could talk with him about it and flip him to a contender at the final years trade deadline.

Also the jets top four looking like:
Enstrom Byflugien
Gardiner Myers
Seems pretty solid to me.


1.) 26 Jul 2016 14:57:28
Another attempt to dump JVR. Sorry no from the Jets. They don't need JVR and don't want Gardner, a 26 year old that makes the same mistakes a 20 year old d-man does. Jets will not trade Comrie as he is Wpg's future #1 and it will take a better package than this for Trouba.

2.) 26 Jul 2016 15:13:05
Would bring toronto pick down to a 3rd maybe 4th and eliminate the 2 picks coming in from peg. But in the same sense peg has wingers and are a budget team and toronto would love trouba but they are high on this goalie they drafted to be a steal.

3.) 26 Jul 2016 15:43:41
I can make an argument both ways. I think WIN could do better moving both guys separately. JVR and Gardiner are both good players, don't get me wrong but I'm not convinced WIN is desperate enough to settle the Trouba situation that they would move those two young players.

4.) 26 Jul 2016 16:33:45
Isn't hellybuck the jets future #1 island jet?

5.) 26 Jul 2016 19:58:14
Hellebuyck and Comrie. What a nice problem to have in 2/ 3 years. One of them will fetch a great return in the trade market.

6.) 26 Jul 2016 23:02:14
Islandjet if he's your future number 1 what is Hellebyuck.

7.) 26 Jul 2016 23:15:56
BardownBeauty Hellebuyck will be the Jets #1 for the next 3/ 4 years then either he or Comrie will be dealt for hopefully a good return. This is why good drafting, smart trades, wise free agent signings and patient development has made the Jets future seem bright. I think hockey people realize Chevy took a horrible Atlanta team and has slowly turned it into a model of how to build a successful franchise. That is why the Jets won't make many of the trades posted here, but it is fun to speculate.




LMac0420's rumour replies


Click To View This Thread

24 Jun 2024 03:00:43
Don’t see them fitting under the cap with those signings. Even with getting rid of Jarnkrok, Robertson and Liljegren.




Click To View This Thread

21 Jun 2024 19:43:48
Fair enough.
I’d like to see the leafs get an elite goaltender, I just don’t see them having the assets to be able to get one.
The only really elite goalie available is Saros, and unless Marner waives his NMC or they decide to move Cowan in a package, I think they’ll have to settle for a tandem.




Click To View This Thread

21 Jun 2024 18:58:22
Never said he was great, said the kid has POTENTIAL.
As stated above, on a retooling team he could see top 4 minutes. Not saying he is a Top 4 Dman, not saying he won’t be a bust. Just stating he has more value in a trade for a retooling team than a 29 year old Centre making 2.4 million would for a retooling team.

That all being said if Bahl lives up to his potential and ends up being a top 4 D I just might grab a jersey ;)




Click To View This Thread

21 Jun 2024 17:25:57
You know what you’re right Pinball, the kids a bust don’t even know why Calgary picked him up. Might as well ship him to Toronto for future considerations.

Once that happens you can package him with Kampf and the rights to Samsonov for Saros. Once he’s a Leaf he’ll hold trade value.




Click To View This Thread

21 Jun 2024 13:59:28
I don’t think Pittsburg would want to give up on Pickering that quick.
I do agree that Smith would be a good add for Chicago. Maybe a lower level prospect than Pickering, or just Smith for a 6th.





LMac0420 has no Banter Replies