10 Oct 2018 17:50:42
Columbus Trades

Toronto Trades
1st Round Pick 2019
4th Round Pick 2019
1st Round Pick 2020*

*Conditional only if Panarin resigns with the Leafs.

Some on here might say Panarin is worth more but realistically Panarin probably won't resign with the Leafs and he probably won't be signing in Columbus either, yes Panarin is the best Player in this Trade Proposal but to get a hard nosed 2 way Winger with a good contract, FGauthier might or might not be a NHL regular but he is bigger than Sedlak and makes less in Contract, so Columbus in the big picture will have traded 1 season of Panarin and Sedlak for an NHL Player in Hyman, a Prospect in FGauthier, plus 2 Draft Picks one being a 1st Round Pick, with a possible 1st Round Pick in 2020 if Panarin does resign in Toronto.

For the Leafs with all there Depth in the AHL with Grundstrom, Bracco etc knocking on the door probably next year it makes sense to go for it this year, when WNylander resigns they will be a scoring machine.

Thoughts ?

1.) 10 Oct 2018
10 Oct 2018 18:21:02
Ok. Who are you and what did you do with the real Pinball?

This trade actually kind of makes sense.

Hate to see Hyman go. But you got to give to get.

As a rental, Panarin is worth the traditional pick + player. You’ve made a reasonable offer. May not be enough for CLB, but I would be reluctant to offer more.

You keep posting proposals like this and we all might be able to start taking you more serious again.

2.) 10 Oct 2018
10 Oct 2018 19:06:32
This isn’t bad, but Columbus has already said if they do trade Panarin they would want a ready now guy back like Gardiner and a guy like Kapanen to go with it.

3.) 10 Oct 2018
10 Oct 2018 19:29:51
Value wise from the leafs it’s a lot to give up. But value wise for Columbus, it’s not nearly enough. Hyman is great at what he does. He’s a gritty 3rd liner or can do the grunt work for stars. Gauthier is still trying hard to prove he can be a 4th liner. And then what should be a late 1st and a 4th?! Next to zero chance any of those pieces become nearly what panarin is. Just don’t see that being the best they can get. Think of what you would want for Nylander and then think of a 3rd liner, 4th liner and a late 1st would make you happy? I’m aware he’s younger and more under control, but panarin is also a more proven star still only 25 or 26.

4.) 11 Oct 2018
10 Oct 2018 23:28:36
My guess is if Columbus waits to Trade him they won't get nearly enough at the Deadline, if they keep him he probably does a Tavares and walks away for nothing, I agree it's a hard choice to make plus they have Bobrovsky to make a choice on, I would seriously look at Trading Panarin now before it's to late, my Proposal to me is fair only because Panarin is a UFA after this year.