16 Feb 2015 18:06:30
This will never happen but I just want to know what your opinion on the value is:

Phi: Giroux, Voracek, Coburn
Chi: Toews, Keith, Pick?

1.) 16 Feb 2015
Honestly no for both teams doesn't make sense

2.) 16 Feb 2015
16 Feb 2015 18:17:26
this is silly and both organizations would never even think of doing this

3.) 16 Feb 2015
16 Feb 2015 18:21:26
fairly even but would never happen!

4.) 16 Feb 2015
16 Feb 2015 18:23:39
who cares about the value when the trade will never happen.

5.) 16 Feb 2015
Toews is a proven winner and has everything you need in a leader he has more value then Giroux. that's not taking anything away from Giroux though because he's one of the best players in the nhl

As for the other two big pieces Keith is one of the top five best dman in the league and has been for a long time now. Voracek has always been a solid winger but this year has been a breakout so its tough to say if he's this good or if this year is a one off. to me Keith would also have a little more value here.

As for coburn and the pick they really don't have enough impact on this deal to mean anything

therefore chicago says no and I think it would be easy they have started a dynasty on the backs of these two players so there's no reason changing that.

6.) 16 Feb 2015
Just do Giroux for Keith. Get them to wear each other's jerseys and play the other's position. They look so similar anyway.

7.) 16 Feb 2015
Toews > Giroux

Vorachek is just having a good year, Keith won the noris last year plus Chicago has to take on coburns rubbish contract plus they have to give a pick? Chicago says no plus why would they do this they are such a a good team right now and are cup contenders

8.) 17 Feb 2015
The best player in the game isn't being traded ever