02 Sep 2021 00:05:54
To SJS :
C - Sean Monahan ( 6.37 @ 2 UFA )

To CGY :
C - Tomas Hertl ( 5.62 @ 1 UFA )


Hertl, 27
Monahan, 26


J Gaudreau - T Hertl - E Lindholm
A Mangiapane - M Backlund - M Tkachuk
J Pelletier - D Dube - B Coleman
M Lucic - T Lewis - T Pitlick

N Hanifin - C Tanev
J Valimaki - R Andersson
N Zadorov - C Mackey

J Markstrom
D Vladar


T Meier - L Couture - K Lebanc
E Kane - S Monahan - N Merkley
N Gregor - N Bonino - R Balcers
A Cogliano - L Pederson - M Nieto

M Vlasic - B Burns
R Simek - E Karlsson
M Ferraro - N Knyzhov

J Reimer
A Hill.


1.) 02 Sep 2021
02 Sep 2021 16:22:51
Value wise I see the main difference being 2 years of the slightly younger Monahan for a 1 year of Hertl.

If Hertl had equal term or an extension, I’d lean towards Hertl having the edge in value so Calgary would need to add. Not necessarily too much, like a 2nd/ 3rd or maybe an equivalent prospect.

If it’s just for rental Hertl, then this is an overpay by Calgary. Rentals don’t get much more than picks/ prospects unless it’s a Rental for Rental swap.

Also my guess is Calgary is going retool and compete. Sharks if moving Hertl would be going towards rebuild territory. So Sharks might not see Monahan as a fit for the rebuild. Calgary also May prefer a Right handed RW in place of left handed C in Hertl. Unless of course they move Monahan to get that RW and then have Hertl fill his spot.

So the deal proposed is interesting, would just need fine tuning based on a couple other factors.


2.) 02 Sep 2021
02 Sep 2021 18:51:06
How does Monahan fit into the sharks rebuild? Makes no sense for sharks. They’d want a 1st and a prospect or a player like Mangiapane and a 2nd.


3.) 03 Sep 2021
02 Sep 2021 22:34:56
@nylander I didn’t realize that they are rebuilding. They haven’t really done anything to signal that.


4.) 06 Sep 2021
05 Sep 2021 23:12:43
They haven't really done much to say they aren't rebuilding either. Compared to the other teams in the division, if they have a good season they still are outside of the playoff picture.


5.) 14 Sep 2021
13 Sep 2021 22:13:39
San Jose would have to add.

Monahan is a year younger but he and Hertl both came into the league the same year. With the exception of last year when Monahan was playing injured he's outpointed Hertl every year.

Monahan has 2 years left on his contract Hertl only has 1.

If Hertl had more than a year left on his contract too it'd be a lot closer.