19 Oct 2019 19:41:55
Edm: James Neal first round pick 2020 kris russel Philip Broberg

Njd: Taylor hall extension 9x7.


1.) 19 Oct 2019
19 Oct 2019 21:41:44
The way neal is layin the smack down i'd think edmonton wouldn't care to get hall back.

How about larsson and a pick for Hall? Just kidding.


2.) 19 Oct 2019
19 Oct 2019 22:11:52
That probably wouldn’t look too good on the organization to turn around and trade Neal, especially with the way he’s playing. I’m sure there’s another way to bring Hall back and I think it would be a great idea. If they could bring Hall back with picks or prospects, I’d put them as contenders. I know you didn’t like Hall yupp but would you want him back?


3.) 19 Oct 2019
19 Oct 2019 22:20:22
Yaaa, Too much from Edm. And Russell wouldn’t waive for NJ. I wouldn’t include Broberg either. Just wait and sign Hall in the off season.


4.) 19 Oct 2019
19 Oct 2019 23:08:05
They could probably get Zucker without giving up too much. He’s no Hall but he can play. Minnesota needs to do a rebuild IMO.


5.) 20 Oct 2019
20 Oct 2019 00:26:08
As an Oiler fan I never personally liked Hall since the day he was drafted, But that was a long time ago and I would for sure welcome him back if we can sign him. I think it’s now a great hockey fit for both parties, that’s it that’s all.
To trade for him during the season, I’m not sure what I would give up.


6.) 20 Oct 2019
20 Oct 2019 00:45:02
Hall before NJ: Disappointment for 1st oa.
Hall 1st year NJ: didn’t do much more than when in Edm
Hall 2nd year NJ: actually did something
Hall 3rd year NJ: got hurt early. Season write off
Hall now: meh. Back to his old self.

Neal we knew was probably going to turn it around. Lucic, no. That was the best trade Edmonton has made in a very long time. No way Edmonton trades all this for Hall, who is back to where he was when he left the team. Slightly above average and underperformed for 1st overall.


7.) 20 Oct 2019
20 Oct 2019 02:08:22
I'd prefer to see Oil look at getting a star Dman or an upper echelon Goalie. I think some of the young guys coming up can round out the forwards. McDavid, Draisaitl and Hall would be the best 3 forwards any team has seen probably since. well the last time Oilers had Gretzky, Messier and Kurri.
However, they also had Furh, Lowe, Coffey ect. Its obviously a different league now,


8.) 20 Oct 2019
20 Oct 2019 04:46:37
Hall wouldn't go back to Edmonton after how he was treated.


9.) 20 Oct 2019
20 Oct 2019 05:54:20
A hot start doesn't make Neals value go up that much and russell wouldn't be enticing. Broberg for sure would be the main piece


10.) 20 Oct 2019
20 Oct 2019 11:32:51
Crosby, Malkin and Kessel>> Hall, McDavid and Drais

Also Yzerman, Federov, Hull, Shannahan, Dasyuk, Zetterberg and Robitalis? Detroit 2002 I think. Sakic, Sundin and Forsburg? Lemuix and Jagar+ Whoever.


11.) 20 Oct 2019
20 Oct 2019 15:25:50
Didn’t you say Hall was a cancer in the locker room yupp?


12.) 20 Oct 2019
20 Oct 2019 16:27:21
If Hall is a bust, what is RNH, Yakupov, Pulijujarvi, Pajaarvi, Nurse?


13.) 20 Oct 2019
20 Oct 2019 17:37:49
Big Pass from Edmonton.
Taylor Hall was traded from Edmonton for many reasons. Not sure why Elliot is hinting at Hall back to Edm. perhaps for ratings.

The only way I can see Hall back to edm is an undo button on Larsson with NJ retaining 2M of Hall's salary to get him as a rental before he does his UFA hold out for the highest bidder. If he can show the organization and the fan base that he has grown up and can be a team player in his rental period, then perhaps a UFA offer for a longer deal can be discussed. No way Edmonton commits long term or commits this level of assets towards Hall until he shows them the reasons he was swooshed out are in the past and he's matured.


14.) 20 Oct 2019
20 Oct 2019 20:37:04
Ya that was the big rumor, he wanted to be the man on the team and that all changed when they won the Mcdavid draft lottery.
That was how many years ago now? Different organization and team now, few years of maturity, I believe it would be a welcome fit from both sides myself. I still don’t like Hall as a person, but the hockey player is a great fit on the team now. I think it’s very possible he comes back, but Probably unlikely.


15.) 21 Oct 2019
21 Oct 2019 16:59:21
Man, hall was traded cause he was hitting the bars up to much and bringing younger players. Being a horrible influence. If he was like McDavid off ice he'd be a hockey god, no McDavid but one of the top. And just saying I've personally seen him at the clubs during seasons while in Edmonton a lot.