23 Oct 2016 07:21:50
chicago: TVR + 2017 1st + 2018 2nd
toronto: Marner + 4th

I know it's an overpayment but i read a report that chicago is looking for a forward and tvr is on the block. i really like marner as a young forward that we can control cost for a few years. and the idea of uniting James and Trevor Van Reimsdyk is interesting to me. Getting marner from the leafs would take an overpayment and this definitely would help the leafs rebuild. as much as i'd hate to lose a first and a second, if marner makers it big that would be a steal for us in the long run.

or alternatively we could do something like this:
chicago TVR+2nd
Devils: camalari (25% retained)

this way the devils get a young defenseman and a pick and chicago gets a veteran forward to help right now for our top six and the retained salary would help with our cap hit.

is either trade close? who would add or what would you change in a TVR++ trade for chicago to acquire forward help?


1.) 23 Oct 2016
23 Oct 2016 08:30:40
Your proposals are brutal. In the nicest way possible.


2.) 23 Oct 2016
23 Oct 2016 08:37:39
so everyone says my proposals are bad, but most don't say how they'd improve them. there are some saying why i'm off or why a team wouldn't but a lot just say it's bad or stuff like that.


3.) 23 Oct 2016
23 Oct 2016 09:33:46
We say it's just bad because without making an entire new post, you can't fix this trash you put on this site.


4.) 23 Oct 2016
23 Oct 2016 12:37:36
we say its trash cause you genuielly don't understand anything. Like why the hell would toronto want to trade marner? Why would chicago want cammalerli at like 4 mil? And we can't improve them because they can't be fixed because THEY don't MAKE SENSE.


5.) 23 Oct 2016
23 Oct 2016 15:08:26
If you want Marner add Paniran and i still wouldn't do it.


6.) 23 Oct 2016
23 Oct 2016 15:13:29
If you want constructive criticism.

Leafs trading a 19 year old player who just won every award available to him in the OHL and was a 4th overall pick will not "really help the leafs with their rebuild"

Last thing on the leafs brass mind is doing family favours for a player who is a year away from unrestricted free agency (jvr)

and the difference between getting marner over cammalerri is not adding a late first rounder while getting an extra fourth back

Think about it from other teams perspective if you don't want to get called out. You say people just say it's bad but don't tell you why, you just told us this is good for torontos rebuild (when clearly it's not) but didn't say why.


7.) 23 Oct 2016
23 Oct 2016 15:43:11
Gardiner, 2nd, 3rd
for
Towes

If you want to continue making stupid offers.


8.) 23 Oct 2016
23 Oct 2016 15:59:00
The problem is you think it's an over payment from hawks when really it's an over payment from the leafs. TVR is an undrafted, 25 year old defenseman who hasn't done a whole lot so far at the NHL level. You add a late 1st and an even later 2nd to try and make it look good. Marner is a 19 year old, 4th overall pick that has looked like he's going to be a very good player in the NHL. The leafs pass whether having the brothers play together is interesting or not.


9.) 23 Oct 2016
23 Oct 2016 16:14:00
Not a chance you get Marner. Clearly a Hawks fan. Dumb post. The worst overpayment I've seen for TVR.


10.) 23 Oct 2016
23 Oct 2016 18:57:50
Kaner, I did try constructive criticism and telling you how they were bad in the beginning. Nothing personal. Sorry man.


11.) 23 Oct 2016
23 Oct 2016 19:25:55
Constructive criticism would go farther with you than with Tanke, I assume. But it won't go nearly far enough to make it worth anyone's while, because you just don't listen and keep posting trash.


12.) 24 Oct 2016
24 Oct 2016 00:01:38
Kaner, how many beers before the post? Cheers bud 🍻.


13.) 24 Oct 2016
24 Oct 2016 07:08:44
BeeJay96 i'm straightedge so zero beers.


14.) 24 Oct 2016
24 Oct 2016 17:53:09
Probably worse proposal I've seen on here
I had to make an account and just to post that.

An overpayment LOL that's hilarious.
Hawks 1st and 2nd rd picks are basically 2nd and 3rd picks. So your trade a superstar in the making in Marner, for a 2nd rd and 3rd picks plus a dman who basically is the same as the other 3-4 dman on the leafs. Which is Average.