NHL Trade Rumors Member Posts


EdmOil's Profile

Current Avatar:
No Avatar image uploaded

No Profile Picture uploaded


Where from:

Favourite player:

Best team moment:



EdmOil's Posts and Other Poster's Replies To EdmOil's Posts



To EdmOil's last 5 rumours posts


To EdmOil's last 5 rumour replies


EdmOil's rumours posts with other poster's replies to EdmOil's rumours posts


16 Oct 2018 21:35:39
Long shot, but something to post!
Oilers: Nurse + Puljujarvi + B prospect like Jones
Leafs: Nylander + Gardiner
Leafs get immediate help on defence and a good right winger with a ton of potential and a B prospect for defence.
Oilers get help for Draisaitl and a puck moving dman which they need desperately.

Now cap space is an issue for the oilers:
Oilers: 1st round pick 2020 + Lucic + Benning
Panthers: Petrovic + Screviour

Oilers line up:
RNH - McDavid- Ratty
Rieder - Drai - Nylander
Khaira - Strome - Screviour
Caggiula - Brodziak- Kassian

Klefbom- Larsson
Gardiner- Petrovic
Russel - Bouchard


1.) 16 Oct 2018 23:06:42
I’d do it as a leaf fan.

2.) 17 Oct 2018 00:00:50
I think Nurse/ Pulj+a 2nd may be better than throwing in Jones imo. Leafs take it if its Jones, idk if EDM would. Seeing that your an Oiler fan, if you want Nylander/ Gardiner, I think that's a fair swap, Nylander >> Pulj, but Nurse >> Gardiner.

As for the Petrovic deal, I think that's not bad, I just don't know if Florida does it. That 1st is a great asset, but idk if they'd have enough cap to accommodate Lucic with Barkov/ Hub/ Ekblad deals. But if they do, I think that's pretty good.

3.) 17 Oct 2018 02:25:48
Ya Caleb Jones has actually had a super good trianing camp, pre season and start to the AHL season, I don't se then adding him just yet to this deal.
I don't mind the deal, but would just rather Nurse Jan Gardiner just because of the uncertainty of Gardiners contract rumors being high high $ after this season. I'm kinda torn here. Like the idea, but unsure really.

4.) 17 Oct 2018 02:47:09
Gardener got 50 points last year, I don’t think nurse is better. Maybe age and defensively a little bit but James the better skater and clearly more offensively gifted. Leafs lose that trade, oilers add the second and jones and even then not sure.

5.) 17 Oct 2018 05:36:15
Nurse is actually a great skater. Definitely love the idea of getting better now instead of waiting and waiting for the future. I’d hate to lose Nurse but I’d love Nylander on Draisaitl’s wing. Oil won’t have the cap for this even with the Florida trade I'm guessing. It would be an easy no if I was more confident in Puljujarvi but I’m still leaning towards no personally. Good thought and I also think there’s better D out there for Nylander.

6.) 17 Oct 2018 12:13:19
Far fetched but interesting. Lucic waiving for panthers would definitely take some convincing. But I’m at least intrigued.

7.) 17 Oct 2018 15:48:10
I think Lucic might waive for the panthers. It’s a warm place with a decent team and he won’t get much attention there. He doesn’t want to play for a Canadian team.
Plus, Lucic is a decent player but his contract is a burden, and as long as he is being played on the 2nd line, the team will suffer. It’s worth sending a 1st rd pick that shouldn’t be top 15 or so.
For me, I think the GM screwed up and the coach is stubborn. They should be gone first.



29 Jun 2018 06:00:00
We all heard the rumours about Lucic. His family is in LA. He wants to be close to them. Kings, Sharks, and Ducks won’t want him. Coyotes are the best option.

Coyotes: Strome
Oilers: Lucic and 1st 2019

Oilers get good cap space. Also, Strome isn’t working out with the coyotes. Maybe with his brother and his friend, McDavid, things would be better for him. He is also a first round pick with good potential.
Arizona gets good leadership for the young talented players and they get a 1st rounder.


1.) 29 Jun 2018 06:28:51
I saw the article you got this from and as I don’t think coyotes would part with Strome for that, I do believe they would consider moving him if oilers added another piece that makes it interesting. Just idk what they’d add.

2.) 29 Jun 2018 16:43:03
Yah no way the Yotes touch that Strome still has potential imo Lucic just about cancels out all the value the 1st holds.



15 Jun 2018 07:37:48
Everyone knows Lucic wants a change.
I’ve heard Hurricanes want to get grittier.
Oilers need to add a sweetener.

Oilers: Lucic + 10 Pick
Hurricanes: Skinner + 2nd round + Williams (cap dump)


1.) 15 Jun 2018 08:53:03
I thought Lucic loved everything about being in Edmonton?

2.) 15 Jun 2018 14:52:46
Okay, so hurricanes give up a 26 year old top line winger who almost hit 40 goals a year ago and has averaged 30g/ 82 for his last 5 years, making $6 mill plus add in a high 2nd to take on lucic and get 10th overall?! Hahahaha

And I love how you have made sure to point out that Justin Williams with his 51 pts this season for 4.5mill and one year left is a cap dump but lucic and his 34 pts with 5 years at 6 mill is somehow an asset in all this lol get real.

3.) 15 Jun 2018 14:58:30
Teams have paid mid first round picks or top prospects to get rid of contracts that were better than lucics. Now lucic still probably has some game left, so there’s a bit of value there probably. So paying the 10th overall could rid you of him and maybe you could get a very small add back. A 26 year old 30 goal top line winger, 50 pt second line winger and a 2nd rounder is not a small add haha.



09 Jun 2018 20:49:41
There is talk about Montreal and Edmonton trade. I noticed people talk about it here.
Oilers: Lucic
Canadiens: Shaw
*Oilers get more cap space and Shaw would look good on 3rd line with Strome.
Lucic would bring grit to the Canadiens. Montreal was interested in him as well.

Three way trade:
Oilers: Petrovic
Panthers: Ho Sang (needs a new scenery)
Islanders: Russel (they need dman especially if De Haan leaves)

Free agents signing by oilers:
Derek Ryan: 1.5 m for 3 yrs
Grabner: 3 m for 2 years

Oilers defence should rebound next season.

Line up:
RNH - McDavid- Rattie
Grabner - Drai - Puly
Khaira - Strome - Shaw
Caggiula- Ryan - Kass
Arberg (46 m approx)

Klefbom- Larson
Nurse - Petrovic
Sekera - Benning
Lowe (23 m approx)

(6.5 m approx)

75.5 m total —> leaves cap space for moves and trades.


1.) 09 Jun 2018 22:55:04
Rather get Ho Sang for Edmonton and work around another trade for petro.

2.) 09 Jun 2018 23:49:30
No way Mtl touches that contract.

3.) 10 Jun 2018 02:13:59
hahahaha no way montreal thouches that if lucic brings grid then keep him because shaw brings grid too on a cheaper contract and is 4 years younger and has 1 year less on his contract. No one wants lucic. Edmonton has to deal with him and montreal won't help you.

4.) 10 Jun 2018 03:07:45
Huh? Petrovic for Russell? Petrovic for HoSang works, but nobody wants Russells contract. was a mistake of a signing, and won't get any positive value for him.

5.) 10 Jun 2018 03:59:55
They did go for weber’s contract, so.!

6.) 10 Jun 2018 15:31:43
Weber and Russell are two very different players. In no world does Russell = Ho Sang or Petrovic. And if Iles want D why not just cut put EDM and do Ho Sang for Petrovic? he's the better D man.

7.) 11 Jun 2018 00:29:38
Why is Russel not close in value with Petrovic? I’ll be honest I was surprised he was an RFA at his age but what do you think he’ll sign for? At very least he’ll be a million cheaper, I’m thinking in between 3 and 4 million? He’s an injury prone D with little offence. In saying that I’m sure he still has okay value. Also I’m a guy that doesn't like Russel and was confused when they gave him that contract but I’ve heard he has value and there’s teams that might want him.

8.) 11 Jun 2018 11:23:19
no, we aren't helping the oilers for God sake, montreal doesn't want lucic. I'll take shaw on top of lucic any day.

9.) 11 Jun 2018 11:24:43
montreal was interested not anymore.

10.) 11 Jun 2018 11:25:43
start by adding the 10OVA or dream on.

11.) 11 Jun 2018 11:27:17
oiler fans would dream about this.

12.) 11 Jun 2018 16:42:51
Holy do Montreal fans say over value their player, nobody wants shaw either, he's way overpaid for a 3-4th line guy, was so happy when Chicago traded him. shaw is what he is, at least lucic could have a bounce back year.



16 May 2018 20:37:52
Oilers: Puljujarvi + Lucic
Canes: Lindholm + Williams

Canes reunite the Finns: Terv + Aho + Puly
Oilers get Lindholm as a two way player on 3rd line with Strome and JJ. Would love that line.
Puly has better potential than Lindholm, so that is where the Lucic and Williams come in.

Oilers: 10 OV 2018 + Russel
Islanders: Ho Sang + Poluck

Islanders get a great pick and Russel to help their defense. Oilers get RHD. Ho Sang has potential but has low value now, so won’t be expensive.


1.) 16 May 2018 21:03:11
Again, for the tenth time, Lucic has a NTC and I highly doubt he would accept a trade to Carolina.
If you have Jujhar on third line wth Strome. Who is the fourth line center? Jujhar should be fourth line center.

2.) 16 May 2018 22:24:37
Islanders trade is interesting.

3.) 16 May 2018 23:03:00
Oilers will try to sign Derek Ryan for 4th line centre.
Of course that’s all if Lucic would accept a trade. I’m looking at fairness of trades.

4.) 17 May 2018 01:48:38
Highly doubt he accepts a trade to Carolina. I think he might accept to Bos, LAK or Van. Ties to all teams. That's only my opinion tho off the top of my head.

And if I'm sending Pul out to Carolina I want at least Faulk back. Faulk and a Winger. Not two forwards. Instead of Lucic (because he wouldn't waive NTC) maybe they would take Sekera back and maybe Sekera would accept to go back to where he's already played.
Puljujarvi, Sekera for Faulk and someone
Maybe add the 10th overall pic and get Faulk and Skinner back.
Reuniting Puljujarvi with Aho would be pretty nice for Carolina. With Svechnikov coming in. Hannifin, Slavin, Pesce. Things are looking up there possibly.

Nuge McDavid Anyone
Skinner Drai anyone
Lucic Strome anyone
Drake Jujhar Kassian

Nurse Faulk
Klefbon Larson
Russell bear / Benning

Huge Finn

Anyone = Rattie, Aberg, Yamamoto. Who ever has best chemistry for a fit.

Or just try and sign a winger for Drai where I have skinner and try trade for OEL around Klefbom and 10th overall. Lol.

5.) 17 May 2018 02:25:25
Pulj and the 10th and a cap dump doesn't get Faulk and Skinner. Replace Sekera w someone else and then there's a better trade. Especially for Carolina, whos loaded on ‘d’, Sekera is nothing more than a cap dump.

6.) 17 May 2018 15:39:18
Well IMO 10th OA = Skinner
And Pul > Faulk by a little bit so Sekera evens that out.
Keep in mind I'm thinking Carolina would love to add Pul to Aho as they are both young Finns. Pul would be so comfortable with Aho. And the Oilers would have trouble keeping this all under the cap even with Sekera going out. But him and his money have to go out in the deal in order to bring those two in. Russell is the other option but Sekera has Carolina ties already.




EdmOil has no Talk Posts



EdmOil's rumour replies


Click To View This Thread

17 Oct 2018 15:48:10
I think Lucic might waive for the panthers. It’s a warm place with a decent team and he won’t get much attention there. He doesn’t want to play for a Canadian team.
Plus, Lucic is a decent player but his contract is a burden, and as long as he is being played on the 2nd line, the team will suffer. It’s worth sending a 1st rd pick that shouldn’t be top 15 or so.
For me, I think the GM screwed up and the coach is stubborn. They should be gone first.




Click To View This Thread

29 Jun 2018 15:28:19
Corey perry’s Contract is worse than Lucic’s.




Click To View This Thread

15 Jun 2018 07:59:07
And what about the salary cap?




Click To View This Thread

10 Jun 2018 03:59:55
They did go for weber’s contract, so.!




Click To View This Thread

23 May 2018 16:50:55
Montreal has enough cap problems with Weber’s and Price’s contracts.





EdmOil has no Talk Replies