23 Jun 2018 19:02:41
How about this.

Buf : 1st overall, eichel, 3rd rounder

Ott : Karlsson, duchenne, 22nd overall

Buffalo still gets a mid 1st rounder and adds a top end center plus the best defenceman in the world

Ottawa saves money while adding 2 future studs without moving the 4th overall.


1.) 23 Jun 2018
23 Jun 2018 19:21:40
I'm shocked that this hasn't happened already. Lol.


2.) 23 Jun 2018
23 Jun 2018 20:05:37
Huge no from buffalo if you want Dahlin or Connor McDavid it’ll take.

Dahlin or McDavid for Karlsson, Tkachuk, Stone, Chabot, White and Ryan ( cap dump )

I’m Implying Dahlin=McDavid

Ottawa could do a full rebuild around Dahlin.


3.) 24 Jun 2018
24 Jun 2018 08:04:44
Karlsson doesn’t get Dahlin. And that sounds dumb because he hasn’t played a game. But Karlsson is one year and Dahlin has the ability to be the best player on your team for 15 years. Craig Button (and I know he can be annoying at times) has been scouting for NHL teams for 30+ years as a scout and GM and Analyst and he says there hasn’t been a D prospect as good as Dahlin since Dennis potvin went first overall to islanders, captained 5 Stanley cups and was first ballot hall of famer. Do I guarantee Dahlin has that same fate? Absolutely not. Do I acknowledge Craig button is smarter with this stuff than people posting rumors on this site? Yes. (Especially Rambo ;) )


4.) 24 Jun 2018
24 Jun 2018 15:02:44
1st of I posted this week's ago. Not sure why it's only showing up now.

2nd off dahlin does NOT = McDavid

3rd off get out of dream world unbiased Jim. Karlsson is the proven best defenseman in the world and proved it in the NHL. Dahlin has great potential sure but he's barely putting up a half a point a game in the khl which is basically a league built around NHL old timers or throwaways and those who aren't good enough to make the NHL with the odd semi talented player in ever 50 to 100 of them. So yeah, Karlsson gets you dahlin and then some no matter how you look at it. Great potential does NOT out weigh proven ability in any way whatsoever!


5.) 24 Jun 2018
24 Jun 2018 15:13:46
And leave it to vbbvbb to post the joke of the day lol

Eichel and duchene are fairly close in stats totals with eichel edging out a bit while dahlin potential and Karlsson proven ability cancel each others value out which would have left the value of that 22nd over the 3rd to make up the slight difference.

So again, tell me how you guys don't undervalue sense players again when you make comments like these?


6.) 24 Jun 2018
24 Jun 2018 15:37:14
Holy crap you are insane Because of age alike eichel is worth a ton more than Duchene not to mention eichel is a batter hockey player. Like holy we don't undervalue Sens players, Duchene is good but no where near as valuable as eichel. You just completely insanely OVERVALUE Sens players daily. It's so crazy.
I'm completely shocked how you defend some of your homer biased thoughts.


7.) 24 Jun 2018
24 Jun 2018 18:55:31
Wow you’re a train wreck man you litterly know nothing you are talking about Dahlins production in the “KHL” when he never played a game there.


8.) 24 Jun 2018
24 Jun 2018 19:51:24
Dahlin in the KHL? Lol do you even know who you are asking about in this trade? That shows how misinformed you are, but just to help you out, Dahlin is supposed to be a lot more complete and all round more like victor Hedman than all offense like Karlsson but.

Karlsson
18 yr old (draft year) 7gp 0g 1a 1pt in top division
19 yr old 45gp 5g 5a 10 pts

Hedman
18 yr old (draft year) 43gp 7g 14a 21 pts in top division
19 yr old. In the NHL

Dahlin
18 year old (draft year) 41gp 7g 13a 20pts in top division.

He played more games in the top Swedish division as a 16 and 17 year old than Karlsson did as an 18 and 19 year old.
Can’t expect you to look at this and use common sense tho to see he’s far more developed into a star at 18 than Karlsson was and projects to be atleast as good and probabaly better. Add in the fact he’s 18, a controllable asset for 8 years minimum and makes $975k for the next 3 years while Karlsson will make 6.5, 11, 11 probably and it’s a no brainer. Also you said hoffman would get a top 10 pick and a top prospect and Sens got scraps for him, so we can wait and see what Karlsson gets and then you can hide for 3 days again.


9.) 25 Jun 2018
24 Jun 2018 22:36:36
Congratulations Rambo, you’ve done it again. I think you win the most delusional award for this site. There has been many come and go over the years, but you bring it day after day. Like yupp said, the 6 year age difference between Eichel and Duchene says it all.

You were right about similar stats but Eichel is just getting warmed up. Karlsson is great, you remind us every day. If Dahlin is half the player Karlsson is, the 10 year age difference says it all once again. From what every anylyst says he’s going to be a stud, which makes him that much more valuable than Karlsson.


10.) 26 Jun 2018
25 Jun 2018 22:40:53
The question is not their value as teens or when Karlsson was the same age you goof it's based on current value NOT Could be value. there's a big difference. my could be value I could say is higher than dahlins does that make it true? No!


Current actuall skill will always rank higher than future could be skill. always has and always will. you don't pass on an opportunity to get the best player in his prime to take a shot that a kid will surpass him. despite how good he's projected it's still not a guarentee where as Karlsson is a guarantee as best defenceman in the world hands down.