18 Jan 2018 19:06:25
Tor: Marner

Ott: Karlsson

Toronto: Get their Franchise dman who they can Resign with a matching contract to Mathews like Kane/Towes

Ottawa: Gets a future possible 100+ point player who can help their rebuild. Ottawa does this only because they're 100% certain he won't Resign in a hypothetical situation. Marner will be undercontrol for 10+ seasons where as Karlsson is just 1.5 seasons.


1.) 18 Jan 2018
18 Jan 2018 19:47:46
Come on! Leafs add big time.


2.) 18 Jan 2018
18 Jan 2018 19:50:59
Hahaha man. Come on 🙄.


3.) 18 Jan 2018
18 Jan 2018 19:53:45
Are you stupid or just stupid? It would cost your golden child to get Karlsson and i don't think that's a price that your franchaise would be willing to pay. You overvalue Marner by far. Kids played one full season so far and it was an average season. He hasn't proved enough to fetch a piece like that. No from Sens, enough said.


4.) 18 Jan 2018
18 Jan 2018 20:05:42
Wow. where to start
Max contract can be 8 years not 10+.

Leafs currently with LTIR have about 3.9M in space, but Matthews bonus is about 2.9 alone w/ o the other players bonus's so about a mill seems to be the cap left.

Karlsson's Salary is 6.5M
Marner's Salary .894 + bonus

Diff 5.606 M

It does get prorated but I don't think that will get Toronto under the cap adding Karlsson's salary for whatever games are left.

Karlson and Doughty are looking for massive pay days @ UFA time which means it's doubtful Toronto will be able to afford to resign him. So is Losing Marner for 1.5 years of Karlson worth it?
Realistically it boils down to Matthews OR Karlsson in Toronto.

Nice dream but realistically If I'm T. O. I'd keep Matthews over Karlsson.


5.) 18 Jan 2018
18 Jan 2018 20:35:38
i really like Marner but i think toronto would have to add here. karlsson has more value.


6.) 18 Jan 2018
18 Jan 2018 20:43:46
Switch Matthews for Marner. Only chance you're getting a one for one there.


7.) 18 Jan 2018
18 Jan 2018 21:02:11
I don't think there has been a person on here to overvalue a player like Nylander has overvalued Marner.


8.) 18 Jan 2018
18 Jan 2018 21:35:18
Holey crap. Why do you overvalue Marner so much? His potential is 70 points, not 100. Smfh. Karlsson is worth much more than Marner, even if EK comes with no extension.


9.) 18 Jan 2018
18 Jan 2018 21:56:41
Let’s see if Marner can string together a few 60 point seasons first before talking 100+, don’t you think?


10.) 19 Jan 2018
19 Jan 2018 01:21:12
The funny thing is he said franchise dman and “potential 100+ guy” lmao.


11.) 19 Jan 2018
19 Jan 2018 05:36:15
If you think marner is a 100+ point guy your on crack nylander is better then marner and Matthews is better then both so if that's the case why don't u put them all on seperate lines and that's 300 points right there so from 3 players your alresdy averaging something like 3.2 goals per game 😂😂😂 that would be some record for sure.


12.) 19 Jan 2018
19 Jan 2018 05:36:54
I said nylander and a pick for ekman Larrson that's reasonable.


13.) 19 Jan 2018
19 Jan 2018 14:45:33
He’s 20 so 10+ years Is reasonable assuming he signs a bridge deal to prove him self before he goes the long term route. And rentals never get back an significant asset like Marner. This would be the most any team has ever given up for a rental in NHL history.


14.) 19 Jan 2018
19 Jan 2018 19:08:26
Dude. enough said lol.


15.) 21 Jan 2018
21 Jan 2018 22:42:31
EK actually still has 1 full year and a half on his contract and is still considered top 3 in world despite a bad year.

I have no problem trading him to the leafs but either Matthews comes back or it's a package deal on both sides that sees

Ottawa : karlsson, Phaneuf, white, a 3rd pick down the road, future considerations

Toronto : marner, nylander, Reilly

Ottawa gets a couple top 6 guys and a solid top 4 defenceman and get rid of Phaneuf contract, nylander and marner can add scoring depth to a top 9 that would be pretty crazy with stone, Hoffman, Ryan, and Duchene while leaving them room to move Smith and brassard and burrows in other deals.

Toronto lands a solid prospect who can slip into an opening left by marner and nylander, an experienced veteran who has a history already with the city, and the best defenceman in the world to solidify their defence core, EK Matthews combo would be deadly.