07 Jun 2017 15:56:40
Calgary
Brodie, Bennett, 2017 1st, 2018 1st

Arizona
Mike Smith, Nick Merkley


1.) 07 Jun 2017
07 Jun 2017 16:09:09
That is terrible. Fair trade 4 all my butt. A 35 year old goalie and a prospect for 2 1sts a top D and growing, 20 year old C. One of the worst trades ever proposed on here.


2.) 07 Jun 2017
07 Jun 2017 16:13:12
edmonton
larson rnh 2017 1st 2018

arizona
mike smith nick merkley


fair? this is basically the same as your trade ft4a lmao.


3.) 07 Jun 2017
07 Jun 2017 17:51:05
Edmonton counters with Pouliot, Hendricks, Jones, and a conditional 4th for OEL. See I can make ridiculous trades too.


4.) 08 Jun 2017
07 Jun 2017 21:37:11
SC4CGY you have me in tears, that was hilarious, you just roasted that guy.


5.) 08 Jun 2017
08 Jun 2017 00:33:12
WOW lol


6.) 08 Jun 2017
08 Jun 2017 03:20:18
This trade is so bad CSKA Moscow would block Arizonas number.


7.) 08 Jun 2017
08 Jun 2017 12:47:26
People who clicked believable: FT4A and all of his alt accounts.


8.) 08 Jun 2017
07 Jun 2017 18:56:08
SC
Far from the same . RNH a #2 Center subbed for bust boy career 3rd liner Bennett. Not. Larrson a #1 Pairing Dman subbed for an adequate 2nd Pair guy. Not. Edmonton's desperate need for a tender. Non existent as Edm has Talbot. Not even in the same ballpark.

Top and SC

Q? here is. Does Calgary want a #1 Tender? If yes you got to pay.
Your pipe dreams of borderline NHL'r / AHL prospects netting a true #1 tender is completely ridiculous and unrealistic. You only find a Kipper for nothing once in a lifetime I'm sorry to say.

Really the meat of the deal is a 2nd Pair dman and a coin tossed into the wishing well in hopes the '18 pick in a better draft year turns into a lotto pick. For a true #1 tender that can help NOW.

If it wasn't such a waste of a draft year. I could understand Bennett + 2017 pick for Merkley could be a bit excessive. but it's moo. doesn't matter what the pick is in '17. anything past perhaps #5 is meaningless. And Calgary gets a coin to toss in that Merkley can exceed BB Bennett.


9.) 08 Jun 2017
08 Jun 2017 19:04:24
SC4CAL

Oh ya. It's so horrible. rates right up there with Ovechkin for AHL / NHL bubble players to Calgary. Please.

Trade is reasonable. Average 2nd pair D and picks ( one of no value in '17) for proven #1 tender within the division and a chance to upgrade from a career 3rd liner to a possible top 6 player. Arizona gets a shot at the '18 draft lotto and a 2nd pair Dman for an elite goalie . Oh no . such a terrible trade because someone gets value for a real tender and doesn't accept Calgary's ridiculous low ball offer of a 4th round pick for a tender.

MG69
Stay with us here. topic is Calgary attaining a #1 elite tender.


McRazzle
Sorry dude. Not like you . only have 1 account.


10.) 13 Jun 2017
13 Jun 2017 10:26:45
Really? Reasonable? Three first round picks (Bennett chosen fourth overall in 2014) and an elite offensive defencman for a 35 year-old goalies and? That suggestion is so absurd. A mind is a terrible thing to waste. It saddens me to realize yours is already wasted. My advice . he11, I've got nothing more than to change your site handle. Your sense of "fair" is akin to that of Donald Trump's sense of reality.