19 Sep 2016 11:32:17
ottawa: ceci, 2nd round pick, neil
edmonton: rnh. yakupov.


1.) 19 Sep 2016
19 Sep 2016 15:20:33
Delete 2nd and Neil from Ottawa and add Karlson because that's the only player that nets RNH from Edmonton! Edm can add prospect Pitlik or Simpson.

Otherwise NO RNH for Ottawa!
Future Selke winner for Past Norris winner sounds about right.

Revised for just Ceci (After the expansion draft June 20th)

Hendrix, Musil.


2.) 19 Sep 2016
19 Sep 2016 15:28:01
Take out Yak and the 2nd and you may have a deal.


3.) 19 Sep 2016
19 Sep 2016 15:56:08
Borje that's just silly.
Edm would jump on the deal, but that's just too far out there. Even for Oiler fans to fathom. lol

Karlson (caz that's the ONLY player that RNH will be traded for from Ottawa),
Ceci,
Neil

for

RNH?
Is just too far out there.


Think Edm better add to make the deal more realistic.
If Yak is out according to you, then that leaves Hendrix, Kassian, Letestu, Lander, Pakarinin, Minor league prospects excepting Ethan Bear to close the deal and 3rd to 7th round picks.

Gonna be a tough sell in Ottawa even with the add.


4.) 19 Sep 2016
19 Sep 2016 16:08:37
K99 Karlsson for RNH is ridiculous. RNH is not a future Selke winner and Karlsson is still in his prime.


5.) 19 Sep 2016
19 Sep 2016 16:49:32
Xcing.
Sorry not ridiculous. and yes he will be. You watch.
RNH has yet to hit his prime.

You want RNH . YOU PAY! End of question. He isn't going for nothing short of an All star.
Not for 2 average Joe players like Ceci and Neil that's for sure.

If an allstar or #1 D isn't in the mix then I'm afraid you're talking to the hand sir if RNH's name is in the trade rumor.

Edm will keep him.


6.) 19 Sep 2016
19 Sep 2016 16:59:16
K99 no RNH doesn't get you Karlsson. Please accept that. I agree Nuge is good but he's not getting a franchise Norris Trophy defenseman.


7.) 19 Sep 2016
19 Sep 2016 17:18:19
K99. I like the enthusiasm but you make some of us Oilers fans look bad man.


8.) 19 Sep 2016
19 Sep 2016 18:08:40
It's actually become a daily ritual for me to look at k99's posts and comments on my breaks to get a good laugh.

His valuation is so far off I have to think he's never watched a game in his life.


9.) 19 Sep 2016
19 Sep 2016 18:21:53
Mc Jesus
Oh agree. something else has to go with RNH to Ottawa. But Ottawa isn't getting RNH + the something else unless it's Karlson in the mix. ( and no. Not for Phaneuf Not for Ceci + other average Joe. . Only Karlson)

It took too long for Edmonton to accrue the organizatioinal Center depth. Can't give it away for average Joe's. or Ceci's / Neil's in this case.

Yup
Don't think of it as looking bad. Think of it as we the Armchair GM's are of the mindset that the Oilers DO NOT want to give up the best 2 way player they have on the team that puts in 100% effort game in and game out. Some players on the team have been accused of less than 100% efforts game in and game out. But not him. Trading the 1 guy ( with respect to Hendrix ) that does put in this effort is a bad organizational move. He's ONLY 23. Best years to come. The trolls know this and push for the undervaluation in the trade. Why do you think he's always listed in trades? Because they want him and want him for nothing to improve their team.
Sorry, this asset is too valuable and you got to play hardball with the trolls trying to attain him for average joe players. If you're a true Oilers fan that watches the games you understand his true value. If you're a Calgary troll, who wishes misfortune upon the Oilers you push for the asset to be gone for the scraps usually listed.

I do not appologize for my valuation of this important piece and give REAL GM PC full marks for not doing something stupid and trading him for the garbage suggested by the people that want him. but don't want to give an equal piece back.


10.) 19 Sep 2016
19 Sep 2016 21:04:36
K99 if you want Karlson it will take

Nurse, Klefbom, RNH and Draistle.


11.) 19 Sep 2016
19 Sep 2016 22:55:17
Please tone it down a little and stop making us look bad. K thanks.


12.) 20 Sep 2016
20 Sep 2016 04:14:15
Don't worry guys, most us know it's the individual and not the oiler fan base. I myself take offense when people group all leaf fans as being delusional. The odd trade proposal I make usually gets bashed by leaf fans.


13.) 30 Sep 2016
30 Sep 2016 15:56:50
LOL I get K99 thinks RNH is worth more than Ceci and Neil, but why did you have to go to Karlsson level?